Skip to main content
AjTrek1
Oct 24, 2018 9:39 PM UTC

Beam vs Playbar/Playbase - My Opinion

Hello

There are a lot of threads asking the question_”Beam vs Playbar/Playbase which should I get?” We all know that the Beam offers more features (i.e. HDMI_ARC, Alexa and AirPlay2). The biggy is sound; IMO primarily vocals/speech, as to how will it fairs in a room of X-Size. The obvious answer is given by Sonos:



I’m going to offer my opinion and feel free to agree or disagree because as I said it’s my opinion. Having both a Playbar and Beam I’ll say this...

Playbar/Playbase
Out of the Box they win hands down versus the Beam; as room size is a non-issue (to a point). More speakers (given Sonos engineers drive for perfection) equate to better music reproduction. Vocals and speech are handled well without augmentation.

The Beam
Music wise it’s better than a Sonos One or Play 1 as stand-alone’s and I dare say the discontinued Play 3. I wonder if there's a replacement in the works for the Play 3. :? Using those same speakers in stereo pairs the Beam falls short. Vocals and speech IMO the Beam sounds better with a sub (augmentation) to handle the low-end in an open space like a Family Room/Kitchen combo. In a bedroom; or slightly larger space with 4 walls, the Beam will do just fine without the sub.

FYI, I have a Beam is an area that is 580 square feet with 18 to 20 ft., ceilings (Family Room/Kitchen combo). Before adding the sub vocals/speech were all over the place; even after using TruePlay. Once I added the sub vocals/speech became lazer focused to the seating area (after TruePlay). It goes without saying that music sounds better also. Just in case you're wondering I have a media room where I mainly watch TV and listen to music. It requires a password to enter:)

So there you have it…my opinion as a Sonos fan! I can’t wait to get my hands on the Sonos AMP. :8

Cheers!
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

16 replies

Edward R
Retired Sonos Staff
Nov 9, 2018 12:08 PM UTC
Hi, AjTrek1. This is an oft asked question. Opinions are subjective (naturally) but I agree with your assessments here. I will definitely be linking users to this thread when I see this question raised henceforth, seems a popular one of late. Thanks for the great content.
Translate
Try searching our articles for help with your question: https://www.sonos.com/en/support
Renowned Enthusiast I
Nov 25, 2018 10:53 PM UTC
Sonos should be embarrassed to still be selling the Playbar. It's ridiculously outdated in so many ways. They need a large and small size Beam. I assume they are working on the but what is taking so long?
I'm liking my beam, sub, sonos one combo but will be getting the AMP so I have real stereo separation upfront and more flexibility in general.
Translate
AjTrek1
AjTrek1Author
Nov 26, 2018 1:18 AM UTC
Ordered the Sonos Amp also!. Should get it December 7th. Can’t wait ?
Translate
Together Everyone Achieves More = T.E.A.M.
Renowned Enthusiast I
Nov 26, 2018 1:20 AM UTC
What are your plans for it?
I got some of the Elacs that were on black friday sale for $150 to use initially but will decided on some tower speakers after that.
Plus the Sonos sub and sonos one rears.
Translate
AjTrek1
AjTrek1Author
Nov 26, 2018 2:20 AM UTC
I'll be using it for pure stereo with a set of "old school" Definitive Technology Bi-Polar BP 20's with black lacquer finish and matching "end table size" Powerfield 1500 sub; also with lacquer finish, adjustable crossover, phase control and level adjustment. Cables used will be Sewell Silverback 12 AWG 259 Strand Speaker Wire with Banana Plugs x 2 and Sewell Direct SW-30455-10 Silverback Subwoofer Cable - Gold Plated, Double Shielded x 1. Will probably replace my B&O turntable for one with a built-in pre-amp.
Translate
Together Everyone Achieves More = T.E.A.M.
Renowned Enthusiast I
Nov 26, 2018 2:22 AM UTC
Whoa very nice.
I was going to buy a different sub but got the Sonos because it was on sale and I had a lot of credits on Amazon through a work rewards program so got the Sonos Sub for $127 🙂
Translate
AjTrek1
AjTrek1Author
Nov 26, 2018 2:26 AM UTC
Hey... I can always use another sub. Got any credits left :8 LOL
Translate
Together Everyone Achieves More = T.E.A.M.
Renowned Enthusiast I
Nov 26, 2018 2:37 AM UTC
Nope :-)
It's from a work rewards program where you get points when you get recognized for doing a good job or whatever. There is a big catalog of things to choose from. I had 30,000 points and I knew the sub sale was coming out so traded in the points for amazon credits and waited a couple weeks for the sale
The sub makes a huge difference in home theater and much more in music than I would have expected. You see all the rave reviews for it and now I see why.
Even so they should have a smaller cheaper sub for Beam owners or people who don't have a very big room.
Speaking of that I got the Beam for $319 no tax and free shipping from AAFES over veterans day and two sonos ones for $149 each from the same place.
So got the whole thing for $744.
These are the Kefs I'm thinking of.
http://us.kef.com/q550
Translate
AjTrek1
AjTrek1Author
Nov 26, 2018 2:48 AM UTC
You should change your on-line name to: TheDealMan 🆒 Those Kef's should get you thrown out of the neighborhood. Very nice! 🙂
Translate
Together Everyone Achieves More = T.E.A.M.
Renowned Enthusiast I
Nov 26, 2018 2:53 AM UTC
Thanks, they are probably overkill for the size of the room and they are the smallest Kef makes but I just like tower speakers.
Plus they are matte black like the Amp 😉
Translate