Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jan 17, 2013 3:12 PM UTC

Sub with Play 3 or Play 5?

Hi, and I apologize if this question has been already addressed somewhere in the forums. I will soon be moving into a two bedroom condo, square footage of about 1100 sq. ft. I am thinking about making the jump to Sonos. I definitely want the Sub, but would it be overkill to get two Play 5's or would it be better to save some money and get two Play 3's? I plan to set up the speakers in stereo mode and put them in my living room.

Any advice will be much appreciated.

Thanks.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    32 replies

    Lyricist III
    Jan 27, 2013 10:24 PM UTC
    Hello,

    I am new in SONOS universe and just ordered 2x PLAY:3 + SUB.

    I wonder if I have made a mistake in not choosing 2x PLAY:5 + SUB.

    As money is not an issue and sound my main concerns, I would like to have more feedback from people who tested both configurations because I can still change my order.

    Does anyone else made comparison between both configurations? When I ordered, I just thought SUB will do job of PLAY:5's boomers so no need for them.

    I will use my system as single room (for now) in my living room + kitchen that is about 50m2.

    I also think PLAY:3 are easier to place and hide as I hate to see any electronic equipment.

    Thank you for you comments.
    Translate
    Jan 28, 2013 1:20 AM UTC

    Does anyone else made comparison between both configurations? When I ordered, I just thought SUB will do job of PLAY:5's boomers so no need for them.



    Read this:

    http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/music-streamers/sonos-sub-review-50008318/

    As stated earlier in this thread, with the play 5s, the differences are subtle, so you will need to see if they are value for the extra cash. It would seem that with the 3s, it is a day/night difference.

    The review doesn't comment on the difference between a 3 pair and a 5 pair, when reinforced by a Sub. Maybe Amadeus can offer his views on a side by side comparison.
    Translate
    Avid Contributor I
    Jan 28, 2013 7:29 PM UTC
    I would love to hear the difference also. Currently I have two paired play 5's and a sub in my bedroom, another play 5 in another room and a connect working with a bose in living room.

    I do plan to add some more Play 5's at some point, but if Play 3's paired with the Sub sound about the same as the Play 5's paired with the Sub then it would make more sense for me to by two Play 3's, pair those with the sub, then move the existing Play 5's elsewhere.

    If Play 5's sounds better with the Sub (even if just a little), then I would prefer to just keep those and add more Play 5's down the road.

    I would think they would sound better seeing that when paired, even if the Play 5 Bass Driver is turned off, then the Play 5 has 4 speakers working (two mids and two tweeters), and the Play 3 would have 3 speakers working (two mids and one tweeter) - or am I missing something (maybe that extra tweeter on each Play 5 just wouldn't really make any difference)?
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Jan 31, 2013 9:33 PM UTC
    Thank you for your comments. I finally changed my mind and ordered 2x play 5 with my sub instead of the 2x play3 initialy planed.

    2 reasons :
    - The line in plug that will allow play CD + TV and all extra mp3 players.
    - I expect the 5 to be better because of its bigger size and additional speakers (heaven if woofers are shut down when used with sub).

    I will get my system tomorrow at my local shop ... lets give a try ...
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Feb 11, 2013 10:37 AM UTC
    Thank you for your comments. I finally changed my mind and ordered 2x play 5 with my sub instead of the 2x play3 initialy planed.

    2 reasons :
    - The line in plug that will allow play CD + TV and all extra mp3 players.
    - I expect the 5 to be better because of its bigger size and additional speakers (heaven if woofers are shut down when used with sub).

    I will get my system tomorrow at my local shop ... lets give a try ...


    Hi, did you eventually get to try this? Currently in the same predicament...!
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Feb 11, 2013 12:50 PM UTC
    2xplay5 + sub sounds great and I'm very happy for not getting the play3 instead.

    After few days of listening, I would say that the addition of the sub is a little more subtle as it does not makes a big difference. It's simply make the sound widder (instead of having 2 speakers source, you will feel that the sound come from anywere in the room - my system is in 50 square meter room). That what I was looking for.

    So I would recommand to get 2xplay5 and try it at home. You should already be very happy with this. Then if you miss something else, then go for the sub, but I would not say it is worth the money. For the same price, you could also go for 4xplay5, it might be better and more flexible.
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Feb 11, 2013 6:46 PM UTC
    2xplay5 + sub sounds great and I'm very happy for not getting the play3 instead.

    After few days of listening, I would say that the addition of the sub is a little more subtle as it does not makes a big difference. It's simply make the sound widder (instead of having 2 speakers source, you will feel that the sound come from anywere in the room - my system is in 50 square meter room). That what I was looking for.

    So I would recommand to get 2xplay5 and try it at home. You should already be very happy with this. Then if you miss something else, then go for the sub, but I would not say it is worth the money. For the same price, you could also go for 4xplay5, it might be better and more flexible.


    Great, thanks for the info. Appreciate the information on size as well. Did you ever notice if the sub turns off the bass unit on the play 5's? Would seem an odd thing to do and not use it for mid-range.
    Translate
    Contributor III
    Feb 12, 2013 9:56 AM UTC
    I run x2 play3's as a stereo pair with the sonos sub. The sound is fantastically blended. I have a single play5 so cannot do a proper comparison. An advantage to consider with the 3's over the 5's is placement. You can mount the 3's pretty much any which way (vertical or horizontal) including using dedicated threaded speaker wall mounts. The fives are a one way fit only.
    Translate
    Lyricist III
    Feb 12, 2013 6:07 PM UTC
    Good point regarding placement. And I also note that the Play 3's are the only ones mentioned to partner with the playbar which seems interesting on the longevity of the 5's...?
    Translate
    jgatie
    Feb 12, 2013 6:14 PM UTC
    Good point regarding placement. And I also note that the Play 3's are the only ones mentioned to partner with the playbar which seems interesting on the longevity of the 5's...?

    Sonos has stated the reason only Play:3s are able to be partnered with the Playbar (quoted from ask.sonos below):

    Gordon M (Official Rep) a minute ago


    SONOS PLAY:5s cannot serve as rears because the PLAY:5 only contains a 2.4 GHz card and the PLAYBAR Audio wireless transmission between the SUB and the rears uses 5 GHz.


    I don't see this as foreshadowing the imminent death of the Play:5.
    Translate