Skip to main content
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 14, 2016 7:22 PM UTC

Is it worth it to add a Sonos SUB to a GEN 2 PLAY:5 stereo pair?

Does anyone see the value in adding a SONOS SUB to a stereo pair of GEN 2 PLAY: 5's?

I've been told that the DSP / crossover functionality of adding the sub to this set would lighten the low end load of the PLAY: 5's, allowing them to more powerfully and clearly produce the mids and highs.

My specific questions:

1. Are there really high and mid frequency benefits to be gained from allowing the sub to handle the low end? Or would the sub just handle the low end, while the highs and mids on the PLAY: 5's sound exactly as they did without the SUB?

2. The pair of PLAY: 5's already deliver substantial bass, so are there even more substantial / noticeable gains to be had from adding the SUB? Or do 2 PLAY: 5's roughly equal the low end output of 1 SUB?

I consider myself a very lightweight audiophile, so I would love to gain more clarity and power if adding the SUB can achieve this, but I do not want to waste the money, if the stereo pair can provide roughly the same clarity and high / mid range power as it already does, while also handling similar low end to the sub?

Many thanks in advance to anyone, who may have input.

Best,

Patrick
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

66 replies

Enthusiast II
Jan 17, 2016 2:45 AM UTC
My point is only that compared to any other sonos stereo pair the SUB affects/improves the sound quality of the other speakers the least.

SUB is great for MOST sonos paired speakers-but $749 for adding "wider, not directional bass"?!? Come on lol
Translate
Jan 17, 2016 2:52 AM UTC
I tested audio by streaming HIFI files from TIDAL PREMIUM, which is usually pretty good. I can only imagine how great they will sound when I stream my own HIFI files from my NAS.

I feel that I have finally created an SONOS setup that is worthy of a junior audiophile. So that makes the addition of the SUB very much worth it for me. It didn't just improve the low end, it improved everything.

Useful report, thank you! I am still looking for a good comparison between a 5 pair+Sub as you have in place, and a 1pair + Sub; I suspect that with bass duties handed over to the Sub in both cases, there will be little difference to be heard.

I have done enough of the audiophile stuff in my life, and based now on my 1 pair + Sub experience, I can say that your 5 pair + Sub set up goes a lot beyond junior audiophile set ups, in sound quality.

And don't hold your breath over the NAS quality - there is no reason why it should sound better than streamed, except expectation bias. I listen to a lot of music from Apple Music and that bought on iTunes, both are 256 kbps lossy files. I can't make out any difference from the same recordings on my NAS, ripped lossless from CDs.

You can, if you choose, do the blind testing to come to your conclusion about the above assertion; or, forget about these trifles and enjoy the music from either source:-).
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 17, 2016 3:41 AM UTC
My point is only that compared to any other sonos stereo pair the SUB affects/improves the sound quality of the other speakers the least.

SUB is great for MOST sonos paired speakers-but $749 for adding "wider, not directional bass"?!? Come on lol


LOL. I completely get your point. I was quite satisfied with my PLAY: 5's even before I added the SUB. I imagine most people would be satisfied with a PLAY: 5 stereo pair as we were...but then I got picky. : ) It helps that I had a generous Best Buy gift certificate and finally found an OPEN BOX SUB! Ha!

I could have spent the same amount of money for better bookshelf speakers, an amp, and a wired sub, but then I either have wires all over my living room OR I'm paying to run wires through the wall and set up in a room not so much intended to look tech-y / man cave-y. SONOS does deliver for the money with a clean, easy set up that does a lot of the DSP / crossover work for you. I have a real / wired 2.1 HIFI setup in my guesthouse, and it is much more of a hassle for me to find the right EQ / bass management setup.

The SUB is a tremendous luxury, but I have no buyers remorse. It is not as much of a bass upgrade as it would be for a stereo pair of PLAY: 1's (which I also love), but my PLAY: 5 + SUB 2.1 setup exhibits a combination of power and clarity that I never imagined I would get from a SONOS streaming system!
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 17, 2016 3:56 AM UTC
I tested audio by streaming HIFI files from TIDAL PREMIUM, which is usually pretty good. I can only imagine how great they will sound when I stream my own HIFI files from my NAS.

I feel that I have finally created an SONOS setup that is worthy of a junior audiophile. So that makes the addition of the SUB very much worth it for me. It didn't just improve the low end, it improved everything.

Useful report, thank you! I am still looking for a good comparison between a 5 pair+Sub as you have in place, and a 1pair + Sub; I suspect that with bass duties handed over to the Sub in both cases, there will be little difference to be heard.

I have done enough of the audiophile stuff in my life, and based now on my 1 pair + Sub experience, I can say that your 5 pair + Sub set up goes a lot beyond junior audiophile set ups, in sound quality....

You can, if you choose, do the blind testing to come to your conclusion about the above assertion; or, forget about these trifles and enjoy the music from either source:-).


One day, I will take my pair of PLAY: 1's out of my bedroom and pair them to the SUB for a taste test. I would imagine that the 5's would at least be louder with more mids at the same volume level as the 1's.

I'll do it soon and let you know how it sounds to my ear. I do this in a large room, so my guess is that the 1's will drown just a bit compared to the 5's as well.

My bedroom is not so big, and my PLAY: 1 pair sounds great in there. I would definitely not want a SUB in my bedroom though. : ) Our teeth would rattle!

At the end of the day, it really is just about the music--whether it's on an iPod, a car radio or some ridiculously expensive audiophile setup. Still, my living room setup currently sounds so great, that I have ceased to notice or look for any flaws.

Thanks for you posts.

Patrick
Translate
Jan 17, 2016 4:11 AM UTC

One day, I will take my pair of PLAY: 1's out of my bedroom and pair them to the SUB for a taste test. I would imagine that the 5's would at least be louder with more mids at the same volume level as the 1's.

I'll do it soon and let you know how it sounds to my ear.


That would be interesting. Remember though that any sound quality comparison must be done with as identical sound levels - not levels on the volume control - as possible, for it to be a valid comparison. The question is - where the sound levels from the 1 pair + Sub are adequate, does the 5 pair + Sub sound any different, all other things including sound levels being identical. The volume control may be set lower on the 5 pair, but that isn't relevant.

The lower volume control levels will only be relevant if the room/user demands higher sound levels, which the 1 pair + Sub may not be able to provide, as is quite likely to be the case in comparison with a 5 pair + Sub. But this is a result of system power, not system sound quality. And the question is where the sound levels that can be delivered by a 1 pair + Sub are adequate, is there any sound quality return for the significantly higher cost of a 5 pair + Sub set up.
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 17, 2016 4:13 AM UTC

One day, I will take my pair of PLAY: 1's out of my bedroom and pair them to the SUB for a taste test. I would imagine that the 5's would at least be louder with more mids at the same volume level as the 1's.

I'll do it soon and let you know how it sounds to my ear.


That would be interesting. Remember though that any sound quality comparison must be done with as identical sound levels - not levels on the volume control - as possible, for it to be a valid comparison. The question is - where the sound levels from the 1 pair + Sub are adequate, does the 5 pair + Sub sound any different, all other things including sound levels being identical. The volume control may be set lower on the 5 pair, but that isn't relevant.

The lower volume control levels will only be relevant if the room/user demands higher sound levels, which the 1 pair + Sub may not be able to provide, as is quite likely to be the case in comparison with a 5 pair + Sub. But this is a result of system power, not system sound quality. And the question is where the sound levels that can be delivered by a 1 pair + Sub are adequate, is there any sound quality return for the significantly higher cost of a 5 pair + Sub set up.


You're absolutely right. I'll make sure to keep the sound outputs the same for both setups...
Translate
Jan 17, 2016 4:28 AM UTC

1. In my somewhat large open space

Plus, my PLAY: 5's are only about 5 feet apart, so the lower end stereo separation is not as noticeable anyway.


Pointing out a seeming contradiction above - this set up dictates that stereo imaging will be available only up to about 5 feet away from the speakers, a very small part of a large listening room.

If you want the stereo illusion to be heard deeper into the room in a larger sweet spot, the speakers need to be further apart, using the equilateral triangle thumb rule. And once you did that, the impact of mono bass from the Sub v stereo bass from the further separated 5 units could be a noticeable factor in driving a preference.
Translate
psmitty77Author
Trending Lyricist I
Jan 17, 2016 4:39 AM UTC

1. In my somewhat large open space

Plus, my PLAY: 5's are only about 5 feet apart, so the lower end stereo separation is not as noticeable anyway.


Pointing out a seeming contradiction above - this set up dictates that stereo imaging will be available only up to about 5 feet away from the speakers, a very small part of a large listening room.

If you want the stereo illusion to be heard deeper into the room in a larger sweet spot, the speakers need to be further apart, using the equilateral triangle thumb rule. And once you did that, the impact of mono bass from the Sub v stereo bass from the further separated 5 units would be a noticeable factor in driving a preference.


I understand you. What I mean to say is what you are saying: my speakers are so close together that I do not benefit from low end stereo separation. For me, it is much harder to determine stereo separation with lower frequencies when the speakers are only 5 feet apart, so having the mono sub is not a big drawback for me.

My couches are set up so that I can have focused listening roughly 5 feet away for maximized stereo imaging--although good imaging is available even several feet beyond that. Still, since the room is big, the PLAY: 5's are powerful enough to fill the room. It is not perfect stereo when I am way back in the kitchen, but it still sounds good enough to cook and eat happily. : )
Translate
Jan 17, 2016 4:51 AM UTC

My couches are set up so that I can have focused listening roughly 5 feet away for maximized stereo imaging--although good imaging is available even several feet beyond that. Still, since the room is big, the PLAY: 5's are powerful enough to fill the room. It is not perfect stereo when I am way back in the kitchen, but it still sounds good enough to cook and eat happily. : )

Fair enough - as always, the last sentence is the most relevant, if it sounds right, it must be right too!

And this also makes it easy for you to do the 1 pair sound quality test. Do it from the same focused listening area from 5 feet away. At that distance the 1 pair will not be constrained for power and allow for a valid apples to apples comparison, by placing them exactly where the 5 units are placed.

For your kitchen listening a 1 pair + Sub probably won't be as good, but my solution for that is to plunk in 1 unit/s in any other place that I need music.
Translate
Jan 17, 2016 5:03 AM UTC
Another thought: Since you have a play 1 pair on hand, and your focused listening is from just 5 feet away, there may be an opportunity to drop 1 units in place of the 5 pair and redeploy the two 5 units to another room, or even rooms. In smaller spaces, just one of the new 5 units ought to do very well, by all accounts.

Sonos is rare in offering these kind of options/flexibility.
Translate