Skip to main content
Sonosjunkie
Prodigy III
Apr 22, 2019 3:31 PM UTC

B&W Formation

https://www.bowerswilkins.com/en-gb

Anyone noticed this announcement? Thoughts?
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    43 replies

    melvimbe
    Apr 22, 2019 5:17 PM UTC
    It's way too early to make much of a judgement call on this. The biggest thing you could really say for sure is that it's priced way too high for a lot of people. On the other hand, it's going to pull in a ton of audiophile types, or perhaps just want to get the most expensive thing possible.

    - The B&W line does have bluetooth though, which will make a lot of people happy. It apparently only has Spotify and Apple music services currently, so you'll likely need that bluetooth, airplay, or your local libraries. It seems to use Roon for local files, and mentions Spotify Connect. I wonder if the app can actually control the music source or if your expected to use the services app.
    - It does a higher bit rate than Sonos does. That will compel a lot of folks, while others will talk about how the higher bit rate makes no difference to the human ear.
    - No mention of voice services.
    - Their soundbar can't be paired with surround speakers currently. They also chose to do an optical connection instead of HDMI-ARC, and do not support DTX. The manual says 'dolby surround', so not sure if that includes DD+.
    - They say that there is zero latency, but they don't specifically talk about latency from video sources, whether it's in multiroom sync or not. Also didn't see anything about whether it uses 5.0 or 2.4 GHz for it's multroom connections.
    - It looks like the control app is Android or iOS, no desktop support.
    - I personally don't like the look of the speakers, but that's subjective. I can see where others may prefer the look.

    Maybe it's interesting not so much as a competitor but in comparison of the feature decisions that were made, and now they compare to Sonos.
    Translate
    Danny
    Apr 23, 2019 1:48 AM UTC
    Ridiculous prices that are needed to support low volume sales/brand marketing. Justifiable only if it offers music play with stability that is orders of magnitude higher than Sonos, close to a wired legacy style system, because at those prices any music stuttering and stopping will be unacceptable. Since that isn't feasible, I can't see many switch from high end wired kit to this.
    Translate
    ratty
    Apr 23, 2019 10:13 AM UTC
    It's disappointing that B&W's marketing department apparently became unmoored from the science (in particular Nyquist-Shannon) and used the long-discredited 'stair-step'/'jaggies' pictures to support their claim of "96/24 Bit Audio Resolution streaming with twice the fidelity than the leading wireless speaker brand for the purest and clearest audio experience".

    I used to appreciate B&W loudspeakers many years ago, and owned a series of mid-priced models, but IMO the above undermines their credibility by playing to the gallery of the audiophile faithful.
    Translate
    Apr 23, 2019 10:29 AM UTC
    I suspect that the stair step jaggies are used to convey the message because there is no better way to do so, never mind that the means and the message are not based in science. And I doubt that this will cost them any loss of credibility with their target market - audiophiles, including those on a budget.
    Translate
    ratty
    Apr 23, 2019 10:45 AM UTC
    IMO the messaging is misleading -- what exactly is "twice the fidelity" anyway? See https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html#toc_sfam

    Other observations:

    The control of these units seems to be via a bit of a mish-mash of apps. The B&W app appears to be mainly for setup and grouping, with some basic playback control. Sources evidently need a native app -- Spotify, Roon, etc. or something which will send via AirPlay or Bluetooth. Presumably radio has to be delivered by AirPlay/BT as well.

    Incidentally the B&W app says it requires "iOS V11.4 or later, or Android V8.1 or later" by contrast with Sonos' continued support of older OSes (notwithstanding recent grumps about the oldest being abandoned).
    Translate
    Apr 23, 2019 10:55 AM UTC
    IMO the messaging is misleading -- what exactly is "twice the fidelity" anyway?
    Erm...twice the number of steps?:-).
    The point I made was that while the message is fallacious; the messaging is the best way to deliver it pictorially because people understand it from where it is valid, for pixels in video.
    Translate
    jgatie
    Apr 23, 2019 1:05 PM UTC

    Erm...twice the number of steps?:-).
    The point I made was that while the message is fallacious; the messaging is the best way to deliver it pictorially because people understand it from where it is valid, for pixels in video.


    No, the "best way to deliver it pictorially" would be to tell the truth. Like extending the dynamic range of a smooth sine wave into the inaudible part of the spectrum. Audio has absolutely no relation to pixels in video, and stair steps (as the Sony case explicitly states) are a lie meant to mislead the consumer. They shouldn't be confused with an attempt to ease the understanding of the layman customer.
    Translate
    ratty
    Apr 23, 2019 1:18 PM UTC
    If there were still around Nyquist & Shannon would not be pleased.
    Translate
    Apr 23, 2019 1:25 PM UTC

    No, the "best way to deliver it pictorially" would be to tell the truth.

    But if one had to sell the high price point, would the truth help? That is what I was saying; given this situation, the jaggies can't be beat for a cool way of misleading the gullible. Who says that marketing is always ethical?
    And it isn't just b&w, the entire HD audio industry is based on this messaging to the misled.
    Translate
    ratty
    Apr 23, 2019 1:28 PM UTC
    Assuming Sonos is the "leading wireless speaker brand" (and a lawyer would have a hard time proving otherwise) they might even consider it defamatory.
    Translate