Skip to main content
Contributor I
Jul 24, 2018 5:32 PM UTC

Airplay with 5.1-setup??

Hi!

I have a 5.1-setup in my living room (Playbar + Sub + 2 x One) and a Sonos One that I move around the house as needed. When the update hit earlier this month my "solo"-One popped up as a speaker option on my iOS-devices, but the surround-setup in the living room did not.

I have read the Airplay 2-guide which was released with the patch, and the guides says that you can use compatible Sonos-speakers (my Ones) in conjunction with speakers (my Playbar and Sub) that are not compatible with Airplay to make the combined unit airplay-compatible. This does not seem to work for me though. I have tried setting up the surround-unit again, but still no luck.

Any tips?
This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

16 replies

melvimbe
Jul 24, 2018 5:39 PM UTC
For a 5.1 setup, the playbar/playbase/beam does all the work (receiving and processing audio) for the room. Because your playbar isn't compatible with airplay, the room isn't. Sonos One can receive airplay 2 when it's playing that role for the room, as is the case for solo Sonos One.

What you probably read was that the playbar can be grouped with a Sonos One that is receiving airplay 2 audio.
Translate
Danny
YerryAuthor
Contributor I
Jul 24, 2018 7:14 PM UTC
Thanks for the reply. What I read was this:

«Gruppér en hvilken som helst Sonos-høyttaler med en kompatibel høyttaler for å gjøre AirPlay tilgjengelig for hele systemet.»

In English this would be «group any sonos-speaker with a compatible speaker to make airplay available for the entire system»

To me that says that my 5.1-system should now be compatible, since the playbar is linked to two compatible speakers.

I don’t have any statistics, but I would think that there are quite a few 5.1-systems with a playbar or playbase out there. Hope Sonos figure out how to make »airplay-tethering» work for surround users too
Translate
jgatie
Jul 24, 2018 8:02 PM UTC
Sonos is very specific with the semantics of their terms. "Grouping" is not "pairing" or "bonding". The link between the Playbar and surrounds is not a "group" it is a "bond". Grouping is when you combine separate rooms together. Pairing and bonding is when you combine different speakers into a semi-permanent room, i.e. a stereo pair or a 5.1 setup.
Translate
melvimbe
Jul 24, 2018 8:15 PM UTC
What jgatie stated is true. I can easily see how people who don't own Sonos, or only have a 5.1 setup can misunderstand the terminology.

As far as Sonos figuring it out, Sonos is aware that it's not an ideal situation for the customer. From my understanding they couldn't make it work technically. Although it's easier for me to say because I'm not personally effected by this, I am somewhat glad that they didn't get it to work. Making this work would be somewhat of a 'hack' and be against the generally design principals of how Sonos was setup to operate. Making changes like this tend to cause problems further down the road, making the system less stable overall, preventing other features from being added, or even having to remove the hack, which is even worse in the eyes of customers usually. That's been my experience anyway.
Translate
Danny
YerryAuthor
Contributor I
Jul 24, 2018 9:39 PM UTC
@jgatie: semantics, really? Thats kind of ironic, isn’t it, when you consider how these products are marketed. :?
Hedging on semantics with something like this seems kind of silly. It should just work like they said it would. Rigth now it really doesn’t. At least for me.

@melvimbe: wow - that comment reeks of patronizing conjecture with a smidgeon of envy. Even when I really tried to read it understandingly. You don’t want Sonos to develop helpful functions for people who own their expensive 5.1-systems? Holy cow, thats just extremely unhelpful. Really, really hope the development guys and gals at Sonos have a more ... constructive and positive attitude towards this.

@Sonos: Please make this work like you said (or I guess; implied) it would. Siri is coming, and I want to command her to make my living room play Pearl Jam!
Translate
Smilja
Jul 24, 2018 10:56 PM UTC
@Yerry, Read this.
Translate
»And the world is like an apple whirling silently in space, Like the circles that you find in the windmills of your mind.« (›Windmills Of Your Mind‹ [1967]. Music by Michel Legrand ; English lyrics written by Alan & Marilyn Bergman)
jgatie
Jul 24, 2018 11:12 PM UTC
It does work the way they said it would. Under the very specific definition of the word "group" in regards to Sonos, you can group a room with another Airplay compatible speaker and both grouped rooms will play Airplay content. What it cannot do is play Airplay content on bonded speakers.
Translate
YerryAuthor
Contributor I
Jul 25, 2018 12:12 AM UTC
@smilja: Thanks! Gotta say I agree with Laura M completely. Except for one thing: I do blame the company. I also feel like I bought two ones instead of 1s on false pretences. I think they will figure this out eventually though. And I actually have an extra One I can use for the ridiculous task of being a Siri/AirPlay 2-relay in the meantime. Then I’ll just buy the playbar II in four years whee it comes out. Sound is awesome regardless. Still feel like they lied, or at least omitted, on this one though.

@jgatie: Again with the bonding. Great for you that you are happy with the status quo. I’m not.

Guess my question has been answered. It doesn’t work. Yet. Good thing these speakers sound awesome, because this really smells of misleading marketing. At least the stuff they wrote up here in Norway. I’m gonna see if some of the publications that propogated this want to get their facts straight at least.
Translate
melvimbe
Jul 25, 2018 12:35 PM UTC

@melvimbe: wow - that comment reeks of patronizing conjecture with a smidgeon of envy.


Envy? I have a 5.1 setup (playbar/sub/play:3), and if I want to use airplay I can do so through other speakers in the house. The situation doesn't apply to me because I don't have Sonos Ones setup as rears anywhere.

Patronizing? I suppose you could read it that way.


Even when I really tried to read it understandingly. You don’t want Sonos to develop helpful functions for people who own their expensive 5.1-systems?


Not what I said at all. My comment was specific to this feature that I know couldn't be implemented in a stable way and may eventually have to removed, causing customers a lot more frustration and disappointment than never having the feature at all.

I was thrilled, when Sonos implemented Alexa integration to existing systems, and glad you can you Alexa through your Sonos Ones as surround. I'm looking forward to the Google integration even though I have no intention of using it myself.



Holy cow, thats just extremely unhelpful. Really, really hope the development guys and gals at Sonos have a more ... constructive and positive attitude towards this.

@Sonos: Please make this work like you said (or I guess; implied) it would. Siri is coming, and I want to command her to make my living room play Pearl Jam!


The implication wasn't their intention. It does suck that you feel mislead on this and I sympathize with this. Sonos statement is correct, but easily misunderstood. I wish they had found a better way to communicate what would and would not work with airplay.
Translate
Danny
Smilja
Jul 25, 2018 12:44 PM UTC
@smilja: Thanks! Gotta say I agree with Laura M completely. Except for one thing: I do blame the company. I also feel like I bought two ones instead of 1s on false pretences. I think they will figure this out eventually though. And I actually have an extra One I can use for the ridiculous task of being a Siri/AirPlay 2-relay in the meantime. Then I’ll just buy the playbar II in four years whee it comes out. Sound is awesome regardless. Still feel like they lied, or at least omitted, on this one though. [...]
Anyhow, I would not hold my breath.
Translate
»And the world is like an apple whirling silently in space, Like the circles that you find in the windmills of your mind.« (›Windmills Of Your Mind‹ [1967]. Music by Michel Legrand ; English lyrics written by Alan & Marilyn Bergman)