Skip to main content
Jun 18, 2019 3:13 AM UTC

Airplay 2 and Sonos: How well do they work together?

With the forthcoming deletion of the ability to play music on Sonos directly from iPhones/Pads, Airplay 2 is widely being seen as a solution. Before investing to bring in that ability via new Sonos hardware as opposed to the more straightforward route of adding a NAS, some questions perhaps need to be answered; questions that arise from not so good experiences with Airplay as it existed before Airplay 2 was released.
  1. Is music play via Airplay 2 to a target Sonos speaker as stable as it is via the "On this Phone" route it is seen to replace ?
  2. Is such music play to a group of speakers also just as stable?
  3. Is music play in both modes above as stable as it is via Sonos net?
  4. Can two phones on the same WiFi network simultaneously stream music each contains via Airplay 2 to unique Sonos speakers in two different rooms?
  5. Can the phones be used as such when music is being streamed from them? Either via the existing feature or via Airplay 2?
These are questions that come to my mind, perhaps there are more that need to be asked before spending money for Airplay 2.
Somehow I am not convinced that Airplay 2 performs as well with Sonos as Sonos net does, except maybe in simple one phone to one speaker set ups. But this is based on using Airplay back in 2011 before realising its limitations and moving to Sonos, with no experience of Airplay 2.
    This topic has been closed for further comments. You can use the search bar to find a similar topic, or create a new one by clicking Create Topic at the top of the page.

    23 replies

    Airgetlam
    Jun 18, 2019 4:03 AM UTC
    1) Yes, it has been for me. Other than the one spot in my kitchen where my iOS device loses the wifi signal, no issues.
    2) Yes.
    3) Yes.
    4) Yes, as much as I've tested it. Don't forget, unless it is really on the iOS device you're doubling the bandwidth use.
    5) Never tested this.
    Translate
    Bruce
    pwt
    Virtuoso
    Jun 18, 2019 8:22 AM UTC
    I agree with Bruce's answers; this mirrors my experience.

    Q5: Yes, it is possible to make calls without interrupting the audio stream. I haven't tried receiving a call, but I'd expect it to work the same way.
    Translate
    4 x P:5 | Sub | 4 x P:1 | 3 x Connect | 2 x Boost | Connect:Amp | 2 x One | Amp | Move | Port | Era 300
    KumarAuthor
    Jun 18, 2019 9:10 AM UTC
    Interesting; that suggests that Airplay has made huge strides in the Airplay 2 version. I suppose the only downside remaining is that of battery consumption of the source device, although this was the case for the "On this Phone" as source as well.
    Translate
    airforceteacher
    Headliner I
    Jun 18, 2019 12:19 PM UTC
    My Airplay2 experience has been 'meh', suffering from dropouts in some instances. Caveat is that I only have one Airplay2 speaker, a Play:5 and it's in the garage, so it's further from the rest of the mesh than any other speakers in my setup. Make sure you purchase somewhere with a good return policy and test your Airplay usage scenarios thoroughly.
    Translate
    KumarAuthor
    Jun 18, 2019 4:04 PM UTC
    Make sure you purchase somewhere with a good return policy and test your Airplay usage scenarios thoroughly.
    And if that isn't possible, it seems to make more sense to go the NAS route that is a well tested solution so long as one doesn't get the few models of NAS that don't make nice with Sonos.
    Translate
    World-Class Superstar
    Jun 18, 2019 4:12 PM UTC
    it seems to make more sense to go the NAS route that is a well tested solution
    For sure! I've been using Sonos-with-a-NAS since 2011, implemented fixed IP-adresses since 2012 and never had any problems. In over 8 years! Am using Spotify to play those songs my music collection doesn't have. The Sonos software could benefit from some improvement, e.g. the playlist management sucks - but apart from that: a happy customer.
    Translate
    pwt
    Virtuoso
    Jun 18, 2019 6:58 PM UTC
    Of course, AirPlay v1 also works with all Sonos players if you run AirConnect [1,2] and configure it correctly. (I'm currently happily listening to a Radio Paradise lossless stream on my iPad, sent in full lossless quality to one of my Sonos Connects.) Works perfectly, every time.

    While there are definite benefits to AirPlay v2 and I like it a lot, AirPlay v1 has the advantage of being supported by a much wider range of Apple OS versions and devices.

    [1] https://github.com/philippe44/AirConnect (open source project)
    [2] https://github.com/pwt/docker-airconnect-arm (Docker image for Raspberry Pi devices)
    Translate
    4 x P:5 | Sub | 4 x P:1 | 3 x Connect | 2 x Boost | Connect:Amp | 2 x One | Amp | Move | Port | Era 300
    Airgetlam
    Jun 18, 2019 7:00 PM UTC
    I would be fascinated to speak to an engineer about it all. It's clear that AirPlay 2 is a step forward, it works substantially better (for me, at least) that AirPlay did....but I'll admit after about 2 weeks, I gave up on AirPlay.

    But obviously there's some processing required at the receiving side of AirPlay 2, due to the way Sonos has implemented it on only newer devices, which would have faster CPUs and more memory on them.

    The one thing that does annoy me currently about AirPlay 2 is that it only handles stereo, and not anything like Dolby Digital. So if I want to watch a movie, I'm better off starting it on my Apple TV, rather than running it on an iOS device and casting to the Apple TV. But then again, I save battery that way. I have to assume that Apple will rectify that in some future update. But really, for me, it's not that important.
    Translate
    Bruce
    KumarAuthor
    Jun 19, 2019 12:24 AM UTC
    Is there - other than HomePods I suppose - any other make that does what Sonos does/did via the " On this Phone" feature? By that I mean without using any version of Airplay? I suppose many would do this via Bluetooth and not need this in the first place.
    I always thought that this feature when introduced was a neat addition that I never ended up using, but never a reason to buy Sonos; if I had that kind of use planned, there would have been many cheaper and equally good sounding bluetooth speakers to choose from. It is therefore strange to hear all the carping about having bought Sonos for just this feature, to be honest.
    Translate
    Airgetlam
    Jun 19, 2019 1:47 AM UTC
    Not that I'm aware of....but haven't looked into it at all, either. Maybe someone who has had a BOSE system or a BlueSound system could comment.

    I think the "carping", as you correctly call it, are people who are not happy with change. It's the way they've dealt with their music for X period of time, and having to change that process is an anathema to them. At one point, I was them, but I learned my way of pointing at the data on the HD on my Mac, and then subsequently moved it to an NAS, when I read about how easy it was to do all of that. And frankly, it is easy. None of this is a substantial change, just a minor change.

    I am concerned that many people are getting the wrong message, though....that iOS will no longer be supported. Which, if you read the information provided by Sonos, is quite untrue. It's merely the "play from this device" which is being removed. I still plan on using my 3 iOS devices to control my Sonos....but on at least one of them, I can now remove the music library, and free up some space.

    I've never quite understood the allure of playing from an iOS device, unless it was plugged in to power. I'm way too OCD about battery levels 🙂
    Translate
    Bruce