If you're getting it out of your XBox, but not out of the Xfinity box, then the issue is in the Xfinity box. Double check that the audio settings for the cable box is set up to output Dolby Digital. If you need to, call the Xfinity folks on the phone, I've see a case or two over the last several years where the cable box was broken, and not actually putting out a Dolby Digital signal.
Still unable to get any answers on this from Xfinity. Is it possible that the Xbox is doing something different that would allow Sonos to recognize the signal as Dolby Digital 5.1?
Ummm, yes? It's sending a 5.1 signal, where the XFinity box isn't?
Have you looked at the audio settings on the Xfinity box? Have you tried swapping the HDMI cables, or even just the HDMI ports that they're plugged in to on the TV, to see if there's a potential failure there?
Yeah, I've tried switching cables/ports and no luck. At this point I think it has to be the Xfinity box. I have my Xbox set to Bitstream out via HDMI. So i wasn't sure if that made a difference.
I believe the audio on an Xfinity box defaults to stereo. You have to switch it to Auto Detect to get 5.1. Also, if Auto Detect is on, it may be having a problem negotiating the handshake. Try unplugging the HDMI and plugging it back in.
Thanks, jgatie. I lost access to my friend's Xfinity box when I moved to Texas...and don't have a lot of memories around how I set it up for her. I'm still a DirecTV user, much more familiar with the Genie interface on that software. Kind of surprised that XFinity's customer service couldn't remote into the box and change the settings....unless there's the remote chance that a) the box is broken, or b) The box doesn't support 5.1 through HDMI. Both would seem unusual to me.
I'm at a loss and I appreciate everyone's response. I'm pretty convinced that the firmware in this STB is not capable of detecting that this Sonos setup is a 5.1 capable system and only detecting that it can deliver stereo. I don't know how else to explain it. I've confirmed that my tv is capable of passing Dolby Digital audio via optical.
I've confirmed that my tv is capable of passing Dolby Digital audio via optical.
"Dolby Digital" can be Stereo (DD 2.0). you need to verify it can pass DD 5.1 when fed from HDMI.
My LG55LWS5700 required me to change settings in the service menu to pass DD 5.1. To get to the service menu I had to buy a $15 remote. I used the information from this site: http://blog.workingsi.com/2012/02/hacking-lg-55lw5700-tv.html
Does the STB from XFinity have its own optical port? If so, you could test by connecting the PLAYBAR to that.
Maybe if you posted the model number of the setop box, we could look up the user manual, and make suggestions as to how to change it so that it's sending a 5.1 signal out through HDMI.
@controlav So this worked! Orded a used version of that remote from Amazon and was able to access the Service menu based on the instructions in that link you provided. Thanks so much.
One thing I found weird was that I could run my cable box through my Xbox One and it would recognize it as Dolby Digital 5.1 (without accessing the service menu).
So the Xbox One must be delivering sound over HDMI in a different way than the Cable Box by itself and when I use the HDMI in, it somehow translates that sound when sending to the TV.
